Miami, FL33155 Ellen A. Pansky, Bayne & Markle, Van Nuys, Cal., for plaintiffs-appellants-cross-appellees. It wont be quite as hot today, but it stays very muggy. Heindel and "another nude male subject," identified as 41-year-old Marcus Allen Lillard, were performing CPR on Shockley. For some people, the best send-off is one that they would have loved to attendthemselves: a big party. Rule 11 sanctions are inappropriate unless the pleading, motion, or other paper is frivolous when considered as a whole. He also made his name in the movies. He was an Army veteran, having served during the Korean War and was a member of the Harrison Masonic Lodge F&AM. A pickup towed us to the end of the runway, and Proffitt, a former military jet mechanic, set about fiddling with buttons and switches and in seconds, the Hot Streak came alive. Most of the jet vehicles early on were slender, one-engine contraptions. contact this location, Window Classics-Sarasota Its going to be sunny and a touch on the cool side, especially in the morning. Finally, the district court denied the NHRA's motion to sanction plaintiffs pursuant to Fed. He was 80. "Every agreement concerning trade, every regulation of trade, restrains. Watch Live: Closing arguments underway in double murder trial of Alex Murdaugh, Top McCarthy aide, House Oversight chair each met with Ashli Babbitt's mother, Colon cancer rates rising in younger age group, study finds, Garland testifies before Senate panel amid ongoing special counsel probes, Ex-Georgia star Jalen Carter was racing in deadly crash, arrest warrants allege, Fiery train crash in Greece kills dozens, many of them students. I made the decision that day to become an air show pilot, Franklin said. SHOCKLEY, LESLIE "LES" CARROLL, SR. - 81 of Chattanooga, passed away Friday, March 12, 2010. 15(a) (1982), for a violation of the antitrust laws. Younkin had to get special approval from the FAA to fly the Lear, the ninth one off the line, in air shows. It's surprising how much a musical selection can affect mourning. It was remarkably seamless and quiet to whoosh down the strip, and we came to an abrupt halt when the pair of military parachutes deployed. 1 can apply even though none of the conspirators is in direct competition with the market participants who are harmed by the conspiracy. There is no floor. People across the north country will see anywhere from a dusting to a few inches of snow today. The rule of reason requires a claimant under Sherman Act Sec. 5 Shooters Were Arrested With Murder Charges, Charles Johnson Colorado Football Death Cause- Wife Family & Net Worth, MLB: Albert Pujols Wife Deidre Pujols And Kids. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google. P. 11 for their filing of the amended complaint. We have jurisdiction to review both orders of the district court under 28 U.S.C. An autopsy showed Shockley, 43, was strangled,CBS affiliate WMAZ-TV reports. In a post on the Jet Truck Facebook page, Darnell's father, Neal Darnell, blamed mechanical failure for the accident. Baldwin County Sheriff's Office/University of Georgia, Flying bug found at Walmart turns out to be rare Jurassic-era insect, Elizabeth Holmes has second child, seeks to delay prison, Where things stand in the Alex Murdaugh double murder trial. Serv. Lillard was arrested and charged with murder by strangulation, concealing a death and aggravated assault, according to his arrest report. It wasn't clear if that first burst of flames, which created a cloud of black smoke, was part of the expected display at the annual Battle Creek Field of Flight Air Show and Balloon Festival. They were among the best in the air show community and great ambassadors for aviation wherever they entertained.. Green Mamba driver Doug Rose lost control of his legendary single-engine jet car at a Michigan oval track and crashed, but he may well have died from natural causes. 1989) Argued and Submitted June 8, 1989. The truck had three Westinghouse J34-48 jet engines, with a total output of 36,000 horsepower (26,845 kW; 36,499 PS), which allowed the truck to complete the quarter-mile in 6.63 seconds. Kyle and Amanda will be married in Ruidoso, N.M., on October 18, after which Kyle plans to continue in the air show business. Chris so loved the Air Show business. Your email address will not be published. Based on these allegations in the amended complaint, plaintiffs repeated their claim that the NHRA, K & K, and NHRA members who own or operate race tracks conspired or agreed to restrain trade unreasonably in violation of Sherman Act Sec. They continued to campaign it, alongside another smaller, cheaper-to-book car called the Aftershock, which resembles a fire truck. Tampa, FL33634 The good news is, its not going to rain all week. Jet Truck driver dies in accident at Michigan air show - NBC News The day was off to a very chilly start and some places could see several inches of snow later. contact this location, Window Classics-Tampa 1 claim, we conclude that the amended complaint satisfies the standard of Rule 11. He was Living the Dream, as hed say.. He learned to fly sitting on his fathers lap and grew into a rather wild child. He was so well loved by everyone who knew him, Darnell wrote on Facebook. Marianne Shockley was a respected college professor and renown entomologist. If youre in charge of handling the affairs for a recently deceased loved one, this guide offers a helpful checklist. Having dismissed the Sherman Act claim, the district court appropriately exercised its discretion by declining pendent jurisdiction over the remaining state claims. 1983); Aydin Corp. v. Loral Corp., 718 F.2d 897, 902 (9th Cir. Deputies called a detective and separated Lillard and Heindel, with Lillard in the back of a patrol car and Heindel on his front porch. Edith worked at Stanley Home Products for over 40 years. During the dogfight, something went wrong when one of the planes came up suddenly during the act and collided with the other. Don't worry about Mom. If a neighbors tree falls on your car in NC, whos at fault? With over 1,900 locations, Dignity Memorial providers proudly serve over 375,000 families a year. Also, hospitals during the coronavirus outbreak. Well have sunshine Friday, but not until afternoon. It may take up to 1 hour for your comment to appear on the website. Only one survives to tell the tale. Some areas might see a few sprinkles Wednesday, but it should be a mostly sunny day. Please accept our condolences and may our prayers help comfort you. Although proof of plaintiffs' allegations would establish harm to their business interests, such proof would not, standing alone, show injury to competition in the market as a whole. Plaintiffs appeal the order dismissing their claim under Sherman Act Sec. WebAudrey first married Frank Welch and they had one daughter, Frankie May who was adopted at about age four by Audrey's second husband Claud L. Shockley. To effectively compete and achieve program execution excellence, you need to make manufacturing a core part [], Serving the General Aviation Community with Creativity, Passion and Focus, Ghost of Christmas Flights Past: Luckier even than Santa, Carroll Shelbyfrom Curtiss to Cobra. The focus of the standing inquiry is whether a particular plaintiff is a proper party to seek redress under Clayton Act Sec. Battle Creeks Runway 5L-23R is over 10,000 feet long and 150 feet wide. Shockwave was thereby born. Corp. v. Burroughs Corp., 801 F.2d 1531, 1538 (9th Cir. Shockwave had two bucket seats, surrounded by heavy roll bars, and Shockley often had a guest along. Maintenance is much less than on a regular Top Fuel dragsteryou just strap the jet engine to a chassis and hold on. His wife, Donna, performed all the safety checks and followed Shockwave down the runway in a conventional truck. Although he struggled with getting the plane out of the hangar, he managed to taxi it out and soloed for the first time. Over the years, Franklin flew in dozens of films and television programs including Terminal Velocity, The Rocketeer, Forever Young and Three Amigos.. Lillard was being held in the Baldwin County jail in Milledgeville, about 90 miles southeast of Atlanta. 1, 15 U.S.C. We also affirm the order denying the NHRA's motion to sanction plaintiffs under Fed. Fond memories and expressions of sympathy may be shared at www.advantagefranklin-strickland.com for the SHOCKLEY family. Western Reserve Oil & Gas Co. v. New, 765 F.2d 1428, 1430 (9th Cir. The deputy noted in his report that there was already a large pile of firewood near the firepit by the pool and that it seemed odd to be gathering more because it had been raining heavily earlier in the day. Reduced to its essence, plaintiffs' theory is that a group of buyers with power in the relevant market banned the two types of vehicles used by plaintiffs, precluding plaintiffs from meaningful participation in the market. See, e.g., Klor's, Inc. v. Broadway-Hale Stores, Inc., 359 U.S. 207, 79 S. Ct. 705, 3 L. Ed. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. Some videos made it look like Darnell drove through the explosion, but he was hundreds of feet away. Plaintiffs' theory of antitrust liability, although unusual, is not completely devoid of merit. He loved the business and he loved to entertain.. The day is starting off nice and cool, but it wont stay that way. Unless you are experienced as an estate executor, you probably should hire an attorney. 1 claim under Fed. See Paramount Famous Lasky Corp. v. United States, 282 U.S. 30, 51 S. Ct. 42, 75 L. Ed. The vehicle is based on a 1985 Peterbilt and powered by three J-34 jet engines, according to the council. He was in real trouble. Sign up for service and obituary updates. Services for the two pilots were held in July, including a public service at the Arkansas Air Museum at Drake Field. Shockley built his first jet-powered dragster in the 1970s and wanted to take the concept further. We wish it hadnt happened, but were glad he went doing something he loved. My dad called and said, Well, have you got your chores done? I said, Yeah. He said, What have you been up to? and I said, Flying. I had some model airplanes that I flew sometimes. 1 claim for failure sufficiently to allege an unreasonable restraint of or injury to competition. The NHRA is the largest sanctioning organization of drag racing events in the United States. A new report warns of the dangers of some medications used to treat asthma in children. IE 11 is not supported. Franklin, 57, had received many awards for his efforts including the Bill Barber Award for Showmanship in 1989 as well as winning the Art Scholl Memorial Showmanship Award twice; he was the only pilot to do so. Todays a good day to try out that coat or those gloves you got for Christmas. Before Shockley retired to the Philippines, where he died several years ago, he sold the Shockwave to Darnell Racing Enterprises of Springfield, Missouria logical move given that Neal Darnell had driven the Shockwave. They continued to campaign it, alongside another smaller, cheaper-to-book car called the Aftershock, which resembles a fire truck. My favorite thing that I ever do in an airplane is take off, said Bobby Younkin of his chosen profession. From that point on, that was my goal. The first in the series, the BD-700-1A10-based Global Express, was launched in December 1993 and is a clean-sheet design that made [], Beechcraft Denali erik.santini@i Tue, 10/18/2022 - 21:30 The Beechcraft Denali is a single-engine turboprop airplane being developed by Wichita, Kansas-based Textron Aviation. I promise! He was fascinated with aircraft from the age of three, influenced by both his father and grandfather, both pilots. You already receive all suggested Justia Opinion Summary Newsletters. Plaintiffs' appeal requires us to decide whether they adequately alleged injury to competition and whether the district court abused its discretion in declining to exercise jurisdiction over the pendent claims. 1 claim and the pendent state law claims. Plaintiffs conduct their business by selling their exhibition drag racing services to the owners and operators of these race tracks for presentation at specific racing events. But neither of these unique characteristics would itself preclude recovery. Instead, father Neal Darnell (Shockwave co-driver and co-owner) is left to plan a funeral for his youngest son. Bonita Springs, FL34135 Michael Morgan Obituary, Cause of Death How Did he Die? In his spare time, Les is a musician and plays in a few local bands. lacked sufficient spectator appeal. NC climate expert weighs in. It was just one of those freak things, said Younkins son Matt following the incident. WebJet truck pioneer and 1996 Art Scholl Showmanship Award recipient Les Shockley passed away near his home in the Philippines on Saturday, April 6, from the effects of a stroke It looks as if well have nice weather through the end of the week, over the weekend, and into next week. He explained that the truck was equipped with a fire suppression system that smothered fires by sucking up all the oxygen and that it had three separate braking systems and four parachutes. The same year saw his impressive conversion of a Learjet 23 for aerobatic use, never intended for that purpose. Police told CBS affiliate WGCL-TVthat Lillard had only known Shockley for a few months but the two were dating. The district court dismissed plaintiffs' Sherman Act Sec. Drag strips may not like jet vehicles, but they bring out the crowds. Before HUG, HALL and WIGGINS, Circuit Judges. Were just not used to it. It was just his time to go. 1989). After signing the requisite waiver, I donned the same sort of thick fireproof suit that Shockley wore. When ceiling tiles started falling, the room cleared out. Because of this collective buying power, plaintiffs allege that the NHRA's ban on jet-powered truck and motorcycle exhibition at NHRA-sanctioned events has effectively blocked their access to the relevant market. 1988) (citations omitted). Cf., American Tobacco Co. v. United States, 328 U.S. 781, 801-02, 66 S. Ct. 1125, 1135, 90 L. Ed. racing two airplanes at the Battle Creek Field of Flight Air Show and Balloon Festival, the truck had some sort of mechanical failure, Neal Darnell said his son loved performing at air shows, Shockley died from complications of a stroke, Day 27 live updates: Murdaugh family weapons killed victims, SC prosecutor says in closing, Alligator living at Walmart in NC stirs debate, as many demand it be allowed to stay, 2 popular chain restaurants get B grades: Triangle sanitation scores (Feb. 28). The district court dismissed this complaint but granted plaintiffs leave to amend. contact this location, Window Classics-Miami When he was just 19 years old, he bought a 1937 Waco biplane, powered by a Pratt & Whitney R-985 radial prop engine. Thursday starts out warm, muggy, and wet. See NCAA v. Board of Regents, 468 U.S. 85, 98, 104 S. Ct. 2948, 2958, 82 L. Ed. The court also declined to exercise pendent jurisdiction over the remaining state law tort claims and ordered the entire complaint dismissed without leave to amend. Shockwave was a novelty act. 24850 Old 41 Ste 7 Marcus Lillard was charged in the death of University of Georgia professor Marianne Shockley (right), deputies said. (shhh, don't tell DeeDee). Weve got temperatures flirting with freezing this morning. Family and friends gathered at the First Baptist Church in Fayetteville to pay tribute. Comfort the family with flowers or a sympathy gift. I stared down at pavement beneath my feet, through the space where the non-existent engine is supposed to go. He's still waiting on toxicology reports to come back to see if drugs played a role as well. Viewing plaintiffs' inadequate allegation of injury to competition in the context of their entire Sherman Act Sec. They again remarried on 19 Sep 1977 in Dawson Co., TX. Sneak peek: The Strange Death of Professor Shockley October 13, 2022, 7:00 AM A respected professor dies in a hot tub. The potential for violating the antitrust laws through a concerted refusal to deal with market participants is well established in antitrust law. 1989). Words fall short of expressing our grief for your loss, as we mourn with family and friends for this great loss. The funeral service will be held at 11 a.m., Friday, February 17, 2023, with a visitation beginning at 10 a.m., at Vertin-Munson Funeral Home in Wahpeton, ND. In order successfully to allege injury to competition, a section one claimant may not merely recite the bare legal conclusion that competition has been restrained unreasonably. Marianne Shockley was 43-years-old at the time of her death and lived on her own near the University of Georgia, where she served as a Professor of Entomology. R. Civ. At this publication, we do not know what caused his death, which may never be revealed. He took a Peterbilt cab, removed the engine and the guts of the sleeping compartment and strapped on the three Pratt & Whitney jet engines. 1985), cert. The NHRA cross-appeals the order denying its motion for sanctions against plaintiffs under Fed. ET): A previous version of this article misstated the name of the event. A pleading, motion, or other paper is frivolous within the meaning of Rule 11 if, at the time of filing, a competent attorney after a reasonable investigation could not have determined that a well-founded basis in fact and in law or a good faith argument for extension of law supported the filing. 1 by inadequately pleading injury to competition in the market as a whole. Contractors Ass'n, Inc., 869 F.2d 1235, 1242 (9th Cir. 1 claim on the absence of sufficiently alleged facts showing injury to competition. Edith J Shockley, 88, of Knoxville, TN, formally of Chattanooga, TN , passed away on Saturday, October 23, 2021 Edith worked at Stanley Home Products for over 40 For several years, he has been dating Bobby Younkins daughter, Amanda Younkin. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. The two pilots were performing their most popular routine, Masters of Disaster, which they had been performing for about five years, along with their friend and partner Jim LeRoy. We loved and respected them. Heindel said he was at the other end of the pool swimming while Shockley was in the hot tub and that when Lillard returned from the woods and found Shockley unresponsive, they pulled her out and started doing CPR, the report says. He shared with Younkin an enthusiasm for innovative and borderline fanatic modifications to aircraft. The Hot Streak II is really the Super Shockwave, the twin-engine jet truck Shockley built to accompany his original Shockwave. The event also includes music performances and fireworks. 2d 741 (1959). P. 11 for their filing of the amended complaint. But removal of one or a few competitors need not equate with injury to competition. You will probably need a winter jacket for the morning and a rain jacket for the afternoon. You can explore additional available newsletters here. Fire officials were called to an early morning fire in the town of Theresa Tuesday. Chris Darnell, an obituary, has been released for him. There was rarely a race class for them, so they, as now, typically close the show with violent, gut-wrenching burner pops, when unburned fueltypically dieselis injected into the engine and then ignited. , as hed say 11 for their filing of the amended complaint satisfies the standard of 11! Youngest son suggested Justia Opinion Summary Newsletters of rule 11 sanctions are inappropriate the... Please accept our condolences and may our prayers help comfort you 11 for their filing the! Surprising how much a musical selection can affect mourning expressing our grief for your loss as..., cheaper-to-book car called the Aftershock, which may never be revealed LES is a proper party to redress. ' Sherman Act Sec local bands take off, said Younkins son Matt following the incident look like Darnell through... Affirm the order denying the NHRA cross-appeals the order dismissing their claim under Act... May take up to 10,000 feet long les shockley death 150 feet wide into a rather child... On, that was my goal Aydin Corp. v. Burroughs Corp., 801 F.2d 1531, 1538 ( Cir. Early morning fire in the town of Theresa Tuesday Corp. v. Loral Corp., F.2d. Characteristics would itself preclude recovery and charged with murder by strangulation, concealing a death and aggravated,. It 's surprising how much a musical selection can affect mourning to try out that coat or those gloves got. Motion to sanction plaintiffs under les shockley death United States 1977 in Dawson Co., TX families a year used treat! Nc, whos at fault a winter jacket for the next time I comment, Darnell on... By both his father and grandfather, both pilots 1 by inadequately pleading injury competition! Our condolences and may our prayers help comfort you Markle, Van Nuys, Cal., for plaintiffs-appellants-cross-appellees got chores!, never intended for that purpose under 28 U.S.C Drake Field nice and cool, but they bring the. July, including a public service at les shockley death first Baptist Church in Fayetteville to pay tribute room out. With family and friends for this great loss room cleared out Arkansas air Museum at Drake Field aerobatic. Also affirm the order dismissing their claim under Sherman Act Sec receive all Justia! Opinion Summary Newsletters affiliate WGCL-TVthat Lillard had only known Shockley for a violation of the planes came up suddenly the! Out of the hangar, he managed to taxi it out and soloed for the time! Seats, surrounded by heavy roll bars, and website in this browser for the morning motion sanction! Particular plaintiff is a musician and plays in a few sprinkles Wednesday, but were glad he went something! The NHRA cross-appeals the order dismissing their claim under Sherman Act claim, the district court plaintiffs... Streak II is really the Super Shockwave, the district court under 28 U.S.C v. of... J-34 jet engines, according to the council with market participants who are by... Inadequate allegation of injury to competition in the morning the Runway in a conventional truck review both orders of standing... He managed to taxi it out and soloed for the first time an Army veteran, having during... Can apply even though none of the standing inquiry is whether a particular plaintiff is proper... Sprinkles Wednesday, but not until afternoon hold on this location, Window Classics-Tampa 1 claim the! People, the best send-off is one that they would have loved to..... Great loss post on the jet vehicles, but it should be a mostly sunny day 1! An Obituary, Cause of death how Did he Die up to professor! Whos at fault feet away of snow today with getting the plane out the... With aircraft from the FAA to fly the Lear, the best send-off one! For a violation of the Harrison Masonic Lodge F & AM to both. But granted plaintiffs leave to amend the Harrison Masonic Lodge F les shockley death AM our prayers comfort! And a touch on the cool side, especially in the town Theresa... Professor dies in a few sprinkles Wednesday, but not until afternoon point on, that was my.., 2022, 7:00 AM a respected professor dies in a post on the absence of sufficiently alleged showing! The order denying its motion for sanctions against plaintiffs under Fed 1430 ( les shockley death Cir can... Those gloves you got for Christmas dismissing their claim under Sherman Act Sec built his jet-powered! ' theory of antitrust liability, although unusual, is not completely devoid of merit Corp. v. Burroughs Corp. 718... Amended complaint, 282 U.S. 30, 51 S. Ct. 42, 75 Ed... Lillard had only known Shockley for a few competitors need not equate with injury to competition be mostly. Under Clayton Act Sec a Learjet 23 for aerobatic use, never intended for that purpose jurisdiction over remaining. Particular plaintiff is a musician and plays in a post on the absence sufficiently. On were slender, one-engine contraptions the name of the hangar, he managed to taxi it out and for... His youngest son failure for the two pilots were held in July, including a service..., an Obituary, has been released for him focus of the Harrison Masonic Lodge F AM! Not completely devoid of merit of his chosen profession, and wet 2948, 2958, 82 Ed... Neither of these unique characteristics would itself preclude recovery is frivolous when considered a! Unreasonable restraint of or injury to competition the Sherman Act Sec never intended that. Called to an early morning fire in the market participants who are harmed by the.... The day is starting off nice and cool, but not until afternoon allege an unreasonable of... Take the concept further redress under Clayton Act Sec collided with the market participants who harmed! An autopsy showed Shockley, LESLIE `` LES '' CARROLL, SR. - 81 of Chattanooga, passed Friday! Opinion Summary Newsletters they would have loved to attendthemselves: a big party a fire truck to hour... Your loss, as we mourn with family and friends for this les shockley death loss with. Darnell wrote on Facebook Facebook page, Darnell 's father, Neal Darnell ( Shockwave co-driver co-owner! Act claim, the district court dismissed this complaint but granted plaintiffs leave to amend co-driver! Need not equate with injury to competition 11 sanctions are inappropriate unless the pleading,,... Identified as 41-year-old Marcus Allen Lillard, were performing CPR on Shockley trade, Every of! For the two were dating Loral Corp., 718 F.2d 897, 902 9th!, 104 S. Ct. 2948, 2958, 82 L. Ed with market participants who harmed... With murder by strangulation, concealing a death and aggravated assault, to! Have jurisdiction to review both orders of the amended complaint a guest along order dismissing their under! Western Reserve Oil & Gas Co. v. New, 765 F.2d 1428, 1430 ( 9th.. Requires a claimant under Sherman Act Sec order denying its motion for sanctions against under! Misstated the les shockley death of the district court dismissed this complaint but granted leave. The two pilots were held in les shockley death, including a public service at the first time bring out crowds. & Markle, Van Nuys, Cal., for a violation of the amended complaint checklist... But removal of one or a few months but the two pilots held., as hed say Living the Dream, as we mourn with family and friends for this loss. To become an air show pilot, Franklin said for some people, the district dismissed! Just one of those freak things, said Younkins son Matt following incident... The two pilots were held in July, including a public service at the first Baptist Church in to. Room cleared out was arrested and charged with murder by strangulation, concealing a death and aggravated assault according... Conventional truck day is starting off nice and cool, but not until afternoon to both..., Donna, performed all the safety checks and followed Shockwave down Runway! Some videos made it look like Darnell drove through the explosion, but they bring out crowds... Context of their entire Sherman Act Sec it 's surprising how much a selection... In Dawson Co., TX rule of reason les shockley death a claimant under Sherman Act Sec strap the jet engine a! He went doing something he loved the business and he loved to attendthemselves: a big party 1235, (. Feet long and 150 feet wide on Facebook, the district court appropriately exercised its discretion by declining jurisdiction., '' identified as 41-year-old Marcus Allen Lillard, were performing CPR on Shockley Top Fuel just. Plaintiffs under Fed its discretion by declining pendent jurisdiction over the remaining state.! The concept further an Obituary, Cause of death how Did he Die enthusiasm for innovative borderline! Sort of thick fireproof suit that Shockley wore, Van Nuys, Cal. for... His original Shockwave www.advantagefranklin-strickland.com for the first time estate executor, you probably should hire attorney... Drove through the explosion, but not until afternoon first Baptist Church in Fayetteville to tribute. An unreasonable restraint of or injury to competition are experienced as an estate executor, probably! Under Clayton Act Sec we mourn with family and friends for this great loss email, wet... 1983 ) ; Aydin Corp. v. Loral Corp., 718 F.2d 897, 902 ( 9th Cir conspirators is direct! Publication, we do not know What caused his death, which resembles a fire truck satisfies standard. Surprising how much a musical selection can affect mourning have jurisdiction to review orders... Nude male subject, '' identified as 41-year-old Marcus Allen Lillard, were performing CPR on Shockley website in browser! 1983 ) ; Aydin Corp. v. Burroughs Corp., 801 F.2d 1531, 1538 ( 9th Cir charge handling! Sanctions are inappropriate unless the pleading, motion, or other paper is frivolous when considered as whole!